A year ago, restaurateurs Steven Cook and Michael Solomonov (Zahav, Percy Street BBQ, Federal Donuts, etc.) opened a pair of restaurants in the 1600 block of Sansom Street. One is straightforward enough….Dizengoff, which is a great little hummus restaurant, a hummusiya, pretty much in the mold of Israeli restaurants of the same type and named after the Tel Aviv street of the same name. Open middays only, it nevertheless has done fantastically well from a business standpoint as well as critical acclaim. Next door at 1623 Sansom is what some folks thought of as Dizengoff’s evil twin, Abe Fisher. Those who couldn’t get past whether or not its cuisine was offensive to Jews, particularly those who kept kosher (the corned pork belly reuben seems to be the go-to example) or was authentically the ”Cuisine of the Jewish Diaspora” as it claimed, had a tough time with the restaurant’s concept. This is not the food your bubbe made, or Cook’s or Solomonov’s bubbes either (both are of Jewish lineage). If you are culturally and/or religiously free of that issue and can look beyond it you are in for a treat. The dinner-only menu consists of three tiers of small plates that excite your palate, defy your stereotypes and break new culinary ground. Yes…it is that good.
With a youthful and bustling soundtrack we began our wonderful dinner. After a pair of savory rugalach came a special small plate for the day, seared foie gras with pickled peach puree, blueberries, smoked walnuts on brioche French toast. What a revelation as the sweet/tart/smoky/buttery elements came to land on my tongue all at once, lubricated by a glass of Hungarian Tokaji. This is a sweet, botrytized wine that was a good alternative to the more common Sauternes pairing. For the rest of the meal, we drank a bottle of Montalbera “la Tradizione” Ruche di Castagnole Monferrato. Ruche is a variety of grape grown in the Piemonte of Italy and the wine was similar to a Burgundy (some say they are related). It was light and acidic with tastes of tart cherry, raspberry, and a touch of cedar. Selected by Brian Kane, the knowledgeable beverage director of the CooknSolo restaurants and manager of Abe Fisher, it fit the broad spectrum of dishes to follow. Now comes a whole host of small plates: salmon gravlax on a potato latke, chopped liver mousse on toasted rye with pastrami-onion jam (more French than Jewish), silky slices of tuna crudo over potato salad, pickled mackerel with Old Bay remoulade, farfel with toasted corn and black truffle, veal schnitzel tacos, and finally a tender-as-buttah slice of skirt steak on Romanian eggplant with marrow butter and Manischewitz steak sauce. This last item was perhaps the restaurant’s most traditional ying to their pork belly yang. Dessert was a blueberry crumb cake with peach compote.
The prices are surprisingly reasonable by Center City standards. Small plates are $10, $12 and $14, and a four-plate prix fixe is available for $39. For those who don’t want to deal with lots of small plates, there are large family style entrees, including dry-aged ribeye with poutine (potatoes, gravy, and cheese curds – a Canadian dish) or Hungarian duck Chinatown-style with kishkes, both serving 2…and a whole Montreal Short rib plate that serves four and is on my personal Restaurant Bucket List. They go for $75, $55, and $65 per person respectively.
I asked Brian Kane if there were any hiccups in the first year of operation. He confided, “It was pretty smooth, but there always are surprises as to how various menu items are received by diners.” The plan for the future is to stick with the restaurant’s concept, which Kane says is to “Take old world Jewish cuisine and reinterpret it in a new American way”. Why not? In the past year it garnered a three-bell Craig LaBan review and was a semifinalist for the James Beard Awards. Moreover, many folks have overcome their initial skepticism and reservations are not easy to come by. Admittedly, some are unable to enjoy Abe Fisher due to their beliefs, but for the rest of us Chef Yehuda Sichel has put together a thrilling take on comfort food that is at once old and new, international and American, familiar and creative, and always delicious.